Welcome to our store
Welcome to our store
Recipient Details
⚠️ Someone 21+ must be available to accept the order at time of delivery. .
Local delivery: A 21+ adult must be present to accept the order and have their ID scanned. If we can't reach the recipient or the ID scan fails, a $8.99 re-delivery fee applies.
Shipping: A 21+ adult must be present to sign. After 3 failed attempts or failed age verification, the order is returned and refunded minus original shipping, return shipping, and a $8.99 restocking fee.
McAfee's Benchmark is a rye-recipe Kentucky straight bourbon produced at the Buffalo Trace distillery. This expression blends the classic craft of Buffalo Trace with a rye-forward approach, yielding a foundation that highlights spice, structure, and a refined bourbon character. The result is a balanced pour that carries the warmth and depth typical of Kentucky straight bourbons, while the rye influence provides a slightly brisker backbone, contributing complexity without overwhelming sweetness. The whiskey has earned recognition from discerning palates, including a 90-point rating from Wine Enthusiast, a commendation that speaks to its consistency, aroma, and flavor profile across multiple tasting sessions.
Historically, McAfee's Benchmark has been celebrated within the spirits community, having earned a Gold Medal and Trophy at the International Spirits Challenge in years past. This track record reflects a trackable commitment to quality, craftsmanship, and competitive excellence on a global stage. The bottle and label often convey a sense of tradition and reserve, aligning with the heritage of its Kentucky roots while inviting curious connoisseurs to explore a nuanced and approachable premium bourbon. In the glass, it offers a spectrum of scents and tastes that invite careful tasting: a bouquet of soft oak, hints of vanilla, and subtle spice can emerge on the nose, followed by a palate that reveals a harmonious balance of sweetness, grain-forward character, and a lingering, satisfying finish. Serve it neat to appreciate its architecture, or with a splash of water or a modest ice cube to open up its layers for a relaxed tasting session.
*Packaging may vary. Our suppliers occasionally update their packaging, labels, or bottle design without advance notice. The product you receive may look slightly different from the image shown — but it's always the same quality spirit inside.
Excellent quality and value. Tastes as good as some more expensive bottles.
Impressed by the quality and depth of flavor. It exceeded expectations.
Super smooth and easy to drink. Great on the rocks.
This bottle was a hit at our gathering. Everyone loved it.

We're committed to making sipsy.com accessible to everyone. If you experience any difficulty using our site or need assistance with an order, please email us at hello@sipsy.com. Our website aims to meet WCAG 2.1 Level AA accessibility standards.